Reader Hookup Confession: My Crush Didn’t Like Our First Kiss

If there’s one thing girls can always bond about, it’s an embarrassing hookup story. Trust us: we all have them. So don’t be shy! Read this OMG reader hook-up confession and then send your own to

Okay, so I had recently been hanging out with a really, really cute guy from my school. He had the best hair and eyes, and he dressed so well (he was so preppy and I loved it). So anyway, one night we were hanging out at my house in basement, watching a movie together with the lights off.

The only problem? Nothing was happening. After a while, I decided that maybe he just wasn’t the type of guy who made the first move. So I slid over next to him and straddled him while he was sitting. He gave me a nervous look, but we started to make out. He was a really good kisser, and I was loving every minute of it.

After about seven minutes into the hair-grabbing and passionate hookup, he broke away from my mouth and said, “I’m sorry, but I can’t do this.” I was shocked, confused, and embarrassed. Then he began to explain that he had been thinking for a while that there was a chance he could be gay. He told me that after a couple of minutes of hooking up, he knew for a fact that he wasn’t into girls. 

I was a little upset, but I tried to hide it. He was so nice, though, and told me how beautiful and great I was, and that none of this had to do with me, and how sorry he was for leading me on. I was pretty embarrassed, but the best part of the whole story is that he and I became best friends afterwards. Right now, he is my closest friend and helps me out whenever I need advice. He is just the best guy! Overall, although it was pretty embarrassing trying to hook up with him when he totally wasn’t into it, I got my best friend out of it, and I regret nothing!

Do you think you can top this confession? Send your hook-up confessions to Don’t worry: they’re totally anonymous.


Read more hilarious hookup confessions here!

Follow Gurl, pretty please!
FacebookTwitterTumblr and Instagram

Posted in: Hookup Confessions
Tags: , ,
  • TheRealist

    Simple. They know that they’re cute, them being your best friend is what makes them cute, your best friend tends to have similar taste in guys, and gay guys (in my experience, no stereotypes intentionally being made) tend to dress better.

  • Amy

    Why are the cute ones either jerks, your best friend, your BFF’s crush or gay? Ladies…guys suck.:)